Watering young black wattle trees, then adding mulch and compost, was associated with higher biomass carbon stocks in a two-year dryland experiment in Ethiopia. The integrated treatment produced the highest reported average, while planting-pit size had no significant overall effect on total or aboveground carbon.

The peer-reviewed study by Abrha Brhan Gebre and co-authors, published in PLOS Climate, examined Acacia mearnsii plantations in Tsirae Wenberta, in eastern Tigray. The team compared four treatments: no added management, watering, watering with mulch, and watering with mulch and compost. Each was tested in pits measuring 30 or 50 centimeters. The experiment included 144 trees across 24 plots, monitored for 25 months.

The combined treatment—watering, mulching and compost, or WMC—had an estimated average total biomass carbon stock of 140 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent per hectare. The unmanaged control averaged 47 tonnes. Watering alone averaged 88.4 tonnes, and watering with mulch averaged 116 tonnes. These are estimates of carbon in tree biomass, converted to carbon dioxide equivalent; they are not direct measurements of emissions avoided or a complete carbon balance.

Management also had a significant effect on aboveground biomass carbon, while pit size did not. The WMC treatment had the highest reported aboveground average, 123 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent per hectare, compared with 38.3 tonnes for the control. The study’s statistical analysis found no significant independent effect of pit size on total or aboveground carbon. That makes the management inputs the clearer factor in these early results.

The pattern below ground was more complicated. Root carbon responded to both management and pit size, with a significant interaction between them. WMC had the highest reported mean root carbon, 16.7 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent per hectare, but the study also found that root-carbon outcomes varied by pit size and treatment. This suggests that a single pit-size recommendation may not apply across all parts of the tree’s carbon stock.

Soil analyses add clues, but not a settled explanation. The researchers reported that WMC plots had lower soil bulk density and higher biomass carbon than the control. Their models also associated soil properties—including sodium, total nitrogen and available phosphorus—with carbon allocation. These statistical relationships do not establish that any one soil property caused the observed differences.

The results matter because restoration projects in drylands need evidence about which early interventions help planted trees establish and accumulate biomass. In this trial, adding water, mulch and compost was associated with substantially higher early biomass carbon estimates for A. mearnsii. That is a useful result for this site and species, but it does not establish how long the carbon will remain stored or whether the same gains would occur elsewhere.

The authors’ conclusion favors WMC combined with 50-centimeter pits. However, their results report no significant pit-size effect on total or aboveground carbon, and the root-carbon response varied with the treatment and pit size. The paper also describes the findings as specific to the local soil, rainfall regime and species; it calls for longer monitoring and trials with more species. The estimates were based on destructive sampling of 24 trees and extrapolated to a per-hectare figure, so the reported values should be read as early biomass-stock estimates rather than proof of long-term climate mitigation.