Paired fins and limbs use a genetic toolkit that may have begun with a different job: patterning the body’s unpaired fins. A PLOS Biology commentary by Caroline Schwaner and T. Nakamura discusses research by Dale and colleagues suggesting that changes in how the gene lmx1b is regulated helped establish dorsal–ventral asymmetry in paired fins. The work offers a possible account of how an old developmental system was adapted as vertebrate appendages evolved, though several steps in that history remain unresolved.

The distinction is between two kinds of appendages. Median fins—the dorsal, anal and tail fins—are unpaired and symmetric across the body’s left–right midline. Paired fins project from the sides of the body and have distinct dorsal and ventral sides. In fish, that asymmetry is visible in fin rays and muscles; in limbs, it is part of the organization of bones, muscles and other tissues. How the developmental program for dorsal–ventral patterning arose in paired fins has been less well understood than how it works in limbs.

In zebrafish, Dale and colleagues found that lmx1bb, one of the fish’s duplicated lmx1b genes, occupies different domains in the two fin types. In paired fins it is found in dorsal mesenchyme, the tissue that contributes to the fin. In median fins it is expressed in posterior mesenchyme, with a pattern that remains symmetric across the midline. The commentary also describes comparisons in paddlefish and several shark species: another patterning gene, wnt7a, showed dorsal–ventral expression in paired fins but symmetric expression in unpaired fins. In zebrafish, lineage tracing found that lmx1bb-positive cells contribute to dorsal fin-ray bone cells in paired fins, while their descendants are distributed symmetrically in median fins.

These findings point to reuse of an ancestral toolkit, but with different regulatory logic. One clue comes from two DNA regions called LARM1 and LARM2, which help control Lmx1b expression in mouse forelimbs. The study found LARM1 sequence conservation in ray-finned and cartilaginous fishes, while LARM2 conservation was restricted to ray-finned fishes. Schwaner and Nakamura note that this pattern suggests at least one LARM may have been present in the common ancestor of fishes with paired fins and limbed vertebrates.

When the researchers deleted both LARMs in zebrafish, enhancer activity for lmx1bb fell in paired fins, but the median fins showed no significant effect. The paired fins also developed a “bi-ventralized” pattern: the ventral fringe features were mirrored on the dorsal fin rays. Median fins were unaffected. These results support a role for the regulatory regions in establishing dorsal identity in paired fins. They also fit with independent findings, discussed in the commentary, that disrupting lmx1bb and the LARMs produces a similar paired-fin phenotype.

The evolutionary explanation remains a proposal supported by comparisons and experiments, rather than a complete reconstruction of the steps involved. The researchers do not yet know which transcription factors directly start lmx1b expression in fins. The commentary raises the possibility that signaling inputs such as Wnt and Hedgehog were rewired, and that the gene en1 was recruited into a new ventral regulatory program. It also notes that En1 has a comparable role in restricting wnt7aa expression in the dorsal pectoral fin, but how that function originated is unresolved.

Together, the results suggest that paired-fin asymmetry emerged as parts of an older developmental toolkit acquired new regulatory inputs and expression domains. That offers a way to connect the patterning of ancestral fins with the later evolution of limbs, while leaving open exactly when and how the relevant changes occurred.