As negotiators meet at the COP31 climate summit in Antalya, Turkey, a central question is how to direct more money to developing countries adapting to a warming world. In an analysis published by The Conversation and republished by Phys.org, Rohit Jindal examines whether carbon markets can help—and why their record in farms and forests gives reason for caution.

Carbon markets let countries or companies that emit greenhouse gases buy credits linked to projects that cut or store emissions elsewhere. Those projects may plant or protect trees or change farming practices. Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum, who is leading the summit, says these markets could raise more than US$50 billion a year in additional finance for developing countries by 2030. That is an estimate, not money already secured.

Jindal draws on two decades studying carbon markets on farms and in forests, including fieldwork in India, Kenya, Malawi, Mozambique, Tanzania and Vietnam. His article is an analysis that draws on earlier papers, field experience and research still under peer review; it does not report one new experiment. He says concerns raised in his early work remain unresolved: poor farmers and people without formal land titles can be left out, while low credit prices and the cost of enrolling many small farms make it difficult for smallholders to benefit.

The funding need is substantial. The article says developing countries need about US$305 billion a year for adaptation, roughly ten times the US$28 billion in international support received in 2024. Countries have called for adaptation finance to at least triple by 2035 and agreed on 59 indicators to track progress. Eleven concern food production and ecosystems, including farms and forests. Some practices promoted by carbon projects—such as improving soils, planting trees and protecting forests—also feature in adaptation efforts.

But the markets remain small relative to their potential. The voluntary carbon market grew from about US$90 million in 2006 to US$535 million in 2024. Buyers that year used about 70 million credits from farm and forest projects, each representing one ton of carbon dioxide cut or stored. Jindal compares that volume with an estimated potential of 8 billion to 14 billion tons a year from farms and forests, saying the credits amounted to less than 1% of that potential.

Jindal identifies three recurring obstacles to scaling projects. First, it can be hard to establish whether a project caused a real reduction: would a forest have been protected or a farmer have changed practices anyway? He cites a large study that found fewer than one in six carbon credits reflected genuine emission cuts. Second, measuring carbon in soil and trees costs money, reducing what farmers receive. In Mozambique, Jindal and colleagues found that a community carbon project raised household incomes only slightly, even with generous contract terms. Third, projects tend to cluster where they are easiest to run. More than three-quarters of projects under the United Nations’ original credit scheme were in China, India and Brazil; Jindal says insecure land rights discouraged investment in African projects.

Projects also face changing weather. In Tanzania’s Uluguru Mountains, Jindal and colleagues offered farmers contracts to plant and protect trees in 2009. Twenty-one months later, 63% of the trees had survived; the article links some losses to failed short rains. The example shows how local conditions can affect a project’s results, even when a contract and planting plan are in place.

Adaptation adds another measurement challenge. Carbon projects can express their results in tons of carbon dioxide, a unit that can be converted into credits and sold. Adaptation has no equivalent common measure: success might mean less flood damage or harvests surviving drought. Such benefits can take years to emerge and are difficult to measure. Jindal argues that adaptation projects may encounter the same barriers as carbon projects, along with this additional difficulty.

His proposed lessons are to keep measurement simple and local, reduce upfront costs, and direct support toward places most at risk rather than only places where projects are easiest to establish. He reports that in field experiments in Vietnam, villagers rarely cheated when monitoring their own work, suggesting communities can help check results. Governments and international organizations could also simplify rules and make it easier for community groups to enroll farmers together, reducing costs for finding buyers, negotiating contracts, securing approval and hiring auditors.

The report’s message is that more adaptation finance is needed, but raising money alone does not ensure it will help. Carbon markets offer a possible channel, while their challenges in verifying outcomes, covering costs and reaching vulnerable communities show why credible project design and measurement matter.