A faint twist in the polarization of the universe’s oldest light could point to physics beyond current theories. But a tiny error in a telescope’s detector alignment can produce a similar signal. A ScienceDaily report published Nov. 17 describes a new method developed by researchers at the University of California San Diego to check for those calibration differences.
The light in question is the cosmic microwave background, or CMB: radiation released when the universe was about 380,000 years old and had cooled enough to become transparent. Its polarization records the direction in which the light’s electric field oscillates. Earlier observations have suggested that this polarization may have rotated by a fraction of a degree during the light’s journey across the universe. The proposed effect is called cosmic birefringence.
If real, the rotation could offer clues to physical processes beyond the Standard Model, the leading framework for fundamental particles and their interactions. But the signal is subtle. A slight misalignment in polarization detectors could create an apparent rotation of much the same kind, making it difficult to tell whether the effect came from the cosmos or the instrument.
The UC San Diego research was led by Postdoctoral Fellow Anto I. Lonappan, Chancellor’s Distinguished Professor of Physics Brian Keating, and Associate Professor of Physics Kam Arnold. The team tested its approach on eight polarization maps made from observations by the European Space Agency’s Planck satellite, which mapped the CMB. The findings were published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
Instead of relying on one combined map, the researchers compared maps made by different groups of detectors. A real cosmic rotation should appear consistently across the maps. Comparing them can therefore reveal differences in the groups’ calibration, helping identify an instrumental problem that might otherwise be mistaken for a cosmic signal.
The method has an important limit: it removes any rotation shared by all the maps. That means it can assess relative calibration differences but cannot, on its own, determine the overall polarization angle or measure how much the universe may have rotated the light. An independent reference is still needed to establish that absolute angle.
The team compared its results with an established method, the Minami-Komatsu analysis. Though the approaches rely on different assumptions, their results were consistent. Combining the new method’s reconstruction of relative calibration differences with an overall calibration value inferred using the established analysis gave an estimated cosmic birefringence angle of 0.37 ± 0.12 degrees. The match is a useful consistency check; it does not independently confirm that the ancient light rotated.
The calibration test could also help future searches for primordial gravitational waves. Cosmologists look for a distinctive curl-like polarization pattern called a B mode that such waves may have produced in the early universe. B modes from gravitational lensing have been observed, but the sought-after primordial signal has not. A calibration error can make some of the stronger, more familiar E-mode pattern appear as B modes, potentially imitating a discovery. The new method could help researchers check for that kind of contamination as measurements become more precise.
Cosmic birefringence itself remains a possibility, not an established finding. Proposed explanations include hypothetical fields associated with axion-like particles, which have not been confirmed and would not necessarily account for dark matter, as well as fields connected to dark energy. The new analysis provides another way to examine measurement reliability; further evidence is needed to determine whether the twist is real and what might cause it.